孔帕尼:凯恩和对手的手臂位置几乎一样,这种情况不该判点球(孔帕尼:凯恩与对手手臂位置接近,此类情况不应判点球)

xtoro

Clarifying penalty context

I'm considering the situation where Kane is playing for Bayern and the coach would defend him. The quote suggests confusion around whether a penalty was awarded to Kane's opponent or if Kane drew a handball penalty. Without clear context, I think it’s best to ask the user what they want – a translation, context, or opinion. I also see options for providing an English translation or a neutral analysis of the Laws of the Game related to handball.Analyzing match details

![tto](/assets/images/FDE34457.jpg)

I want to gather more information by asking which match and time we need to analyze. I think a concise response is the way to go. I’ll provide a translation into English along with a summary of the IFAB handball criteria, focusing on important factors like arm position, making the body bigger, and the implications of a handball during play.

![tor](/assets/images/386FCA5A.jpeg)

I'll also clarify the need for match details and offer to break down the analysis or discuss the call, keeping it succinct and clear without needing disclaimers.

大意:孔帕尼认为“凯恩和对手手臂位置几乎一样,这种情况不该判点球”。

一些规则点供参考(手球判罚要点,按IFAB最新解释):

  • 关键看“手/臂是否使身体扩大(unnaturally bigger)”以及是否处于不自然位置,而不是与对手是否“相同姿势”。
  • 距离与反应时间:近距离被折射/反弹,通常更不容易判罚。
  • 手臂高度与张幅:高过肩或大幅张开更容易被判。
  • 动作结果与意图无强制关联:即使非故意,只要手臂不自然扩大阻挡也可能判。
  • 先打到本方身体再弹手臂,通常降低判罚概率(但不绝对)。
  • 进攻方手球导致直接进球或立即获得机会,通常都会判手球在先。

因此,“两人手臂位置相似”并不能单独成为不判点的依据;裁判会独立评估被判防守方在当时动作是否让身体不自然变大、是否有时间收手、手臂是否超出自然范围等。

如果你指的是某一场具体比赛,我可以结合当时回放和这些判罚标准给出更具体的判例式分析。是哪一场、哪一分钟的那次判罚?